AES JOURNALS
COMMON INFORMATION
HOME
OBJECTIVE
CONTRIBUTIONS TYPES
SUBJECT COVERAGE
MANUSCRIPT PREPARATION
SUBMISSION GUIDELINES
SUBMISSION DEADLINE
SAMPLE PAPER
COPYRIGHT
NOTE
ARTICLE PROCESSING FEE
PAPER EVALUATION PROCESS
FORMAT OF ACCEPTANCE LETTER
REPRINTS INFORMATION
CONTACT INFORMATION
AES EDITORIAL AND REVIEW BOARD
EDITORIAL WORKFLOW
ARTICLE REVIEW FORM
PUBLISHER

 
ARTICLE REVIEW FORM

Name of Article Reviewer:

Date of Review:

Title of Article:

Author of Article:

Please answer YES or NO to the following questions and add further comments as appropriate.

1.  The article title is appropriate.
2.  The abstract accurately reflects the content.
3.  The purpose or thesis of the article is stated clearly.
4.  The purported significance of the article is explicitly stated.
5.  The article adequately ties to the relevant literature.
6.  The research study methods are sound and appropriate.
7.  The literature review and research study methods are explained clearly.
8.  The primary thesis is argued persuasively.
9.  The writing is clear concise and interesting.
10.  All figures, tables, and photos are necessary and appropriate.
11.  The conclusions or summary are accurate and supported by the content.
12.  The article is of interest to many URISA members.

Specific Reviewer Comments and Suggestions:

Please indicate which of the following actions you recommend.

(  )  Publish, no significant alterations suggested.
(  )  Publish, but suggest changes to the article as specified in this review.
(  )  Reject, but encourage author to try a major revision and a second peer review
(  )  Reject, do not encourage a rewrite

Further Reviewer Comments Regarding Disposition of the Article:

 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

AES JOURNALS

Copyright ©2009 Amoghsiddhi Education Society (AES)

Office Address: F/12, Ketki Apartment, Nagraj Colony, Vishrambag, Sangli 416415. (Maharashtra) India